• The added line is THIS COLOR.
  • The deleted line is THIS COLOR.
**Base Damage [#s9777980]
-2H weapons 230% -> ?
-1H weapons 100% -> ?


**Skill ED Change [#ofd7c17e]
**Skill ED Change (New) [#bf04fe8d]

***Amazon Melee [#rd717bbc]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Jab|0+15/lvl||
|Fend|70+13/lvl||
|Dance of Death|-50+8/lvl||
***Single Target (Slow) [#bf8a74a1]
|LEFT:130|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|LEFT:200|c
|Skill|CENTER:Old ED|CENTER:Old ED/L|CENTER:New ED|CENTER:New ED/L|Remarks|h
|Leap Attack|150|50|250|60|Requires some space.|
|Charge|120|30|200|55|Requires some space. Knockback automatically makes the space if the space is available.|
|Bash|200|40|180|45|Knockback prevents continuous attacks.|

***Amazon Ranged [#r71989f4]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Multiple Shot|none|3/4 Weapon Damage|
|Guided Arrow|0+5/lvl||
|Legendary Arrow|0+5/lvl|5/8 Weapon Damage|
|Strafe|5+5/lvl|3/4 Weapon Damage|
***Single Target (Normal Speed) [#vba290a2]
|LEFT:130|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|LEFT:200|c
|Skill|CENTER:Old ED|CENTER:Old ED/L|CENTER:New ED|CENTER:New ED/L|Remarks|h
|Guided Arrow|0|5|100|20||
|Stun|30|8|60|35||
|Concentrate|100|12|120|30|Nerf def bonus a bit|
|Iaigiri|150|20|120|30|Nerf def bonus a bit|
|Berserk|150|15|200|40|Magic Dmg|
|Sacrifice|180|(20-40)|80|50|Life Loss|

***Barbarian Melee [#j8b4cc4c]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Bash|200+40/lvl||
|Double Swing|30+6/lvl||
|Stun|30+8/lvl||
|Leap Attack|150+50/lvl||
|Concentrate|100+12/lvl||
|Frenzy|90+8/lvl||
|Whirlwind|50+10/lvl||
|Berserk|150+15/lvl*|Magic Damage|
***Single Target (Fast) / Multiple Target [#z39f52a4]
|LEFT:130|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|LEFT:200|c
|Skill|CENTER:Old ED|CENTER:Old ED/L|CENTER:New ED|CENTER:New ED/L|Remarks|h
|Jab|0|15|-|-||
|Fend|70|13|-|-|60% -> 80% Rollback|
|Killer Scythe|70|10|70|13|50% -> 80% Rollback|
|Zeal|0|6*|0|10|*after slvl 5|
|Fanatic Swing|0|6*|0|10|*after slvl 5&br;50% -> 100% Rollback&br;2/3 -> 1 Weapon Dmg|
|Double Swing|30|6|50|10||
|Frenzy|90|8|100|12||
|Dragon Claw|100|12|100|14||
|Double Smash|||||Faster than Zeal in Elemental with much WIAS.|
|Iron Claws|15|7|50|7|Faster than Zeal in Elemental with much WIAS.|
|Feral Rage|60|8|80|10||
|Fury|100|17|120|18||

***Whirlwind [#c78ffac5]
|LEFT:130|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|RIGHT:60|LEFT:200|c
|Skill|CENTER:Old ED|CENTER:Old ED/L|CENTER:New ED|CENTER:New ED/L|Remarks|h
|Dance of Death|-50|8|-50|10|Stun|
|Whirlwind|50|10|50|12||

**Skill ED Change (Old) [#dada0392]

***Ranged [#r71989f4]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|Necessary Changes|h
|Multiple Shot|none|3/4 Weapon Dmg|More Weapon Dmg?|
|Legendary Arrow|0+5/lvl|5/8 Weapon Dmg||
|Strafe|5+5/lvl|3/4 Weapon Dmg|More Weapon Dmg?&br;or ED++|
|Phantom Hatchets|none|3/4 Weapon Dmg|More Weapon Dmg?|
|Shuriken|none*||More Weapon Dmg?|
|>|>|>|CENTER:*No ED bonus because Strafe routine can't add Throw ED|

***Assassin Melee [#g59beb13]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Tiger Strike|100+20/lvl|Charge-up skill|
|Dragon Claw||Finishing Skill|
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|Necessary Changes|h
|Tiger Strike|100+20/lvl|Charge-up skill&br;This can be used with&br;Dragon Tail and isn't a&br;true single target skill||

***Assassin Ranged [#v7fa87ec]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Shuriken|none||
|>|>|No ED bonus because Strafe routine can't add Throw ED|
**Animation Speed [#f5fbb2c8]
An attack consists has 3 parameters: Start Frame, Action Frame and Animation Lenght. 
This translates into 3 attack phases. Discounting rounding differences, the phases are as follows. Divide the duration by the speed increase (100+EIAS): 

***Barbarian Ranged [#b6eaf672]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Double Throw|30+8/lvl||
|Phantom Hatchets|none|3/4 Weapon Damage|
First Attack, duration = Action Frame - Start Frame 
Follow-Up, duration = Action Frame * Rollback (only when more than 1 attack, e.g. Zeal) 
Return to Neutral = Animation Length - Action Frame - 1 

rem: reduce the mana cost of phantom hatchets
The Action Frame also defines when the actual attack takes place, the arrow appears, ... 

***Druid Melee [#d13d1af3]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Feral Rage|60+8/lvl||
|Double Smash|20 per charge||
|Fury|100+17/lvl||
e.g. An Amazon has 2 / 11 / 18 animation data with 2h spears. This gives a 9 frame First, 11 frames FU and 6 frames RtN with Zeal or an 15 fpa single attack. 

***Necromancer Melee [#i438a6b4]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Killer Scythe|70+10/lvl||
The Start Frame is not found in the animation data, it may be hardcoded. 

***Paladin Melee [#r43c9da9]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Sacrifice|180+(20-40)/lvl||
|Zeal|0+6/lvl*|*after slvl 5|
|Vengeance|70+6/lvl*|*Elemental Damage|
|Charge|120+30/lvl||
I played a bit with the numbers, here are some first results (based on my calculator, I didn't test anything): 

***Sorceress Melee [#v34074f2]
|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|LEFT:150|c
|Skill|ED bonus|Remarks|h
|Fanatic Swing|0+6/lvl*|*after slvl 5&br;2/3 Weapon Damage|
***Paladin [#k1811cdc]
-2H Swing: 352
-2H Thrust: 352
-2H Sword: 352

With an animation speed of 352 he gets a 4/4/4 Zeal / 8 fpa attack with spears and a 4/4/3 Zeal / 7 fpa attack with 2h Swords and Poles/Staves, ... 

#comment
***Barbarian [#pa62fad0]
-2H Swing: 352
-2H Thrust: 352
-2H Sword: 352

With 352 he gets a 4/4/3 Zeal / 7 fpa attack with all 2h weapons. 

***Assassin [#i6b43c02]
-2H Swing: 404
-2H Thrust: 404
-2H Sword: 404

With animation speed 404 she gets a 4/4/4 Zeal / 8 fpa attack with 2h swords and spears and a 4/4/3 Zeal / 7 fpa attack with Poles/Staves. 

***Druid [#oe91c3fa]
I don't think we need to do anything with the Druid, at least his attacks with 2h weapons are almost the same speed as with 1h weapons.

***Necromancer [#j024edb3]
-2H Swing: 288
-2H Thrust: 288
-2H Sword: 288
-Killer Scythe: 60% rollback

The Necro is only slightly slower with 2h weapons than with 1h weapons. To give him about the same speed I would increase the animation speed to 288. His Killer Scythe currently gets 3.5 follow-up attacks, if we want him to get 4 fpa, we would reduce the rollback to 60%. 

***Amazon [#bc2e64d3]
-2H Swing: 336
-2H Thrust: 336
-2H Sword: 336
-Fend: Reduce ED% for oskill Fend

Increase the animation speed to 336 for 2h weapons, then she gets a 3.5 fpa follow-up with spears and a 4 fpa FU with other weapons assuming 60% rollback. 

One option would be to keep Fend at 60% rollback and make it Amazon specific. To penalize existing oskill items, you could reduce the AR/damage bonus when you don't have any hard points in it (like the elemental Masteries). It would still be useful for other classes as a very fast attack to apply CB, but it might not be that desireable. 

The other option would be to move all the action frames for the zon 2 frames ahead, and increase the attack speed to 352 for 2h weapons, this would give her a 3/4/3 fpa Zeal with spears and 4/5/3 fpa with other 2h weapons. 
With an animation speed of 256 and an action frame 2 earlier, she would get a 3/4/4 Zeal with 1h thrusting and 4/5/4 with 1h swinging weapons. 

If you move the action frame, the animations could look strange, though, because she would then hit earier than before and the animation would rollback before the actual "hit" frame. 

***Sorceress [#r8a7ea8a]
-2H Swing: no change
-2H Thrust: ?
-2H Sword: ?

The Sorc doesn't need any balancing between 1h and 2h weapons, her fastest melee attack is actually with Staves. She is quite slow with 2h swords and spears, though. Fanatic Swing with gives her a decent attack speed (with 50% rollback), but it could use a lower damage penalty and better synergies (especially synergies from skills that are useful to a melee sorc, like in the N patch). 

If you want to give her a useful attack speed with 100% rollback attacks, then you'd have to move her action frames 2 forward, just like the 'zon.


Front Page   New All Pages Search Recent Changes   Help   RSS of recent changes